• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Eat the Bite
  • Home
  • Recipes
  • About
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Welcome to Eat the Bite!
  • Recipes
  • Appetizer/Snack
  • Side Dish
  • Breakfast/Brunch
  • Sandwiches
  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • CSA SERIES
  • Entrees
  • International
  • Pasta
  • Pizza
  • Pork
  • Salad
  • Seafood
  • Stuffed Chicken Breast Series
  • Sweet Things
  • Vegetarian
×

Home » Beef

Dinner for Two: Steak au Poivre with Potatoes Au Gratin

Published: Feb 7, 2023 by Stacey

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe
valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: close up view of one portion

This gourmet steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin will make you feel so good inside. We're approaching Valentine's Day so I thought a special dinner for two would be appropriate for all you love birds out there. Steak is expensive to order at any restaurant so I'm here to save you a ton of money. I bought two filet mignon steaks for about $14. Two steaks!! That is $7 per steak. As you can see I'm very good at math. At a restaurant you will pay $25-30 per steak. So let me make this easy for you: steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin is what you will be serving your honey for Valentine's Day.

What is Steak Au Poivre?

In short, steak au poivre is a cracked pepper encrusted filet mignon served with a cognac cream sauce. It's best to use fresh whole peppercorns and grind them with a mortar & pestle if you have it. If not, you can put the peppercorns in a plastic bag and pound with a mallet or pan to grind them. They should be coarse and will be used to create a crust on the top of your steaks.

coarsely crush the pepper in a mortar and or in a slider bag with a kitchen mallet
Coarsely grind the pepper
season the filet mignon with salt and a coarse pepper crust on the top
Rub and press the pepper on top of the steak to make a crust

The Best Steak au Poivre I Ever Had Was in Brooklyn

I used to visit a friend in Brooklyn and she suggested we have dinner at little bistro called Quercy. She mentioned they had really good steak au poivre and we should get that. I was totally into it. The restaurant was tiny with a sweet blue and white checkered floor and swooping burgundy drapes at the entrance, like you're entering a theatre. I loved that detail.

We both ordered the steak au poivre and you could choose your side and one of the side options was potatoes au gratin. It's very rare to find a restaurant that serves potatoes au gratin so this was very exciting for me, since... I was going to say since potatoes are my favorite food, then decided against it, then decided yes, I should say this one more time. I love potatoes and if you visit my website frequently, (which of course you do) I mention this every chance I get. I'm obsessed with potatoes and it's my desert island food. Were I to be trapped on an island with only one food I could eat forever, it would be potatoes.

overhead view of baking dish filled with potatoes au gratin

The Quercy steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin was cooked to perfection and the potatoes were addicting. Every time. Totally consistent. The peppery crust on top, just enough cracked pepper in the sauce. There was never a morsel of food left behind. This became our regular place when I came to visit. And I know, there is an amazing sauce with the steak, and the potatoes au gratin has a cheesy saucy thing going on too. Is that too much sauce? No. The two sauces meet in the middle of the plate, become best friends and do a little dance together.

valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: steak cut in half and medium rare with sauce and parsley

The Perfect Meat and Potatoes Dish for Valentine's Day

Even though there is a mildly fancy sauce, this meal is not hard to make and it won't break the bank. Going out to dinner is going to cost you, for the steak dinner alone, a good $30 per person. Apart from the $14 it cost for TWO filet mignon steaks, the only other slightly pricey ingredient is the cognac which will be about $8-12. The other costs are incidental: a few potatoes, onion, garlic, peppercorns, butter, potatoes and cheese.

valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: very close view of one steak before it's cut in half

How to Make Potatoes Au Gratin

valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: cube the american cheese and shred the cheddar cheese for the potatoes au gratin
Cube and shred the cheeses
valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: finely dice your onion and thinly slice the potatoes for the potatoes au gratin.
Finely dice the onion and slice the potatoes
valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: line a baking dish with potato slices
Line 11"x7" baking dish with potatoes
add onions to potatoes and a sprinkling of salt
Add diced onion and salt
add cheeses and milk to the potatoes and bake in the oven
Add cheeses and milk & bake on foil-lined sheet pan
valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: the potatoes after they cooled down for 10 minutes
Let the potatoes cool for 10 minutes once out of oven

Easy Steps to Making Steak au Poivre:

season the filet mignon with salt and a coarse pepper crust on the top
Season your steaks and make the pepper crust on top
turn the steaks and cook another 5 minutes
Cook on high heat for 5 minutes on each side
cook onions and garlic in the steak pan with butter... then add the cognac
Start pan sauce with butter, onions, garlic, and cognac
let it cook until the cognac is reduced by about ¾
Let the sauce cook a few minutes to reduce
it should look like this after cognac reduces
What it looks like once cognac is reduced
after cognac is reduced add beef broth and let it reduce in half
Add beef broth and reduce again
add heavy cream and butter and stir while it thickens
Add heavy cream, a little butter, pepper and whisk
remove from heat to continue letting it thicken and it's ready to serve
Remove from heat to let it finish thickening

Happy Valentine's Day to Everyone No Matter What Your Relationship Status is

This is a day for love. All kinds of love. You might be with your partner, your BFFs or your family. It doesn't really matter. But if you can spend the day with people you care the most about it will be a great day. Even better if you can make homemade food and simply enjoy the evening. I encourage all of you to get into your kitchens and try something new. Preparing meals and gathering around a table is an important part of the human experience. It gives us a chance to talk and engage and share our lives. And especially on Valentine's Day - share our love. 💕

Need More Ideas for Awesome Food? I Understand.

  • Pork Chops w/Stove Top Stuffing & Caramelized Apples and Onions
  • The Very Best Creamy Chicken Marsala
  • How to Make Chicken Piccata
  • One Pot Chicken w/Carrots & Fennel
  • Alex Guarnaschelli's Superb Pork Cutlets
  • Cardamom Chicken Thighs w/Coconut Raisin Rice
Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
valentines dinner for two - steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin: overhead view of two portions with cognac and potatoes in background

Dinner for Two: Steak au Poivre with Potatoes Au Gratin


  • Author: Stacey
  • Prep Time: 15 minutes
  • Cook Time: 45 minutes
  • Total Time: 1 hour
  • Yield: 2 portions 1x
Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Description

Dinner for two just got a whole lot better. I've got a gourmet steak au poivre with potatoes au gratin for your special Valentine's dinner.


Ingredients

Units Scale

For the Potatoes au Gratin

  • 3 medium Yukon potatoes
  • 2 ½ tablespoons finely diced onion
  • 1 ½ cups cubed American cheese
  • 1 ¼ cup shredded sharp white cheddar cheese
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • ¾ cup milk

For the Steak

  • 2 beef tenderloin steaks, 1 inch thick (aka filet mignon)
  • 1 tablespoon whole peppercorns, crushed coarsely
  • Salt (see note #1)
  • 1 tablespoon canola oil

For the Sauce

  • Drippings from cooking the steaks
  • 3 tablespoon of butter
  • 1 ½ tablespoons finely diced onion
  • ½ teaspoon finely diced garlic
  • ⅓ cup cognac (I used Hennessey)
  • ½ cup beef broth
  • ¼ teaspoon fresh crushed peppercorns
  • ¼ cup heavy cream (might not need all of it)

Optional garnish

  • Chopped parsley

NOTE: You will need an 11x7 baking dish for the potatoes

 


Instructions

  1. Start with the potatoes au gratin first. Cube your American cheese and shred the white cheddar. I used sliced American cheese from the deli and cut the slices into thick strips and then into cubes.  Set the cheese aside. 
  2. Peel your potatoes and set aside. 
  3. Finely dice the onions for the potatoes and for the au poivre sauce. Divide them into two small ramekins. 
  4. Slice the potatoes into rounds that are about ¼” in thickness. Line the potatoes in rows in an 11”x7” baking dish. Should be able to do three rows. 
  5. Sprinkle the onions over the top of the potatoes, then salt, then add the cubed American cheese and shredded cheddar to the top as well. 
  6. Pour milk over the top of the potatoes. 
  7. Line a sheet pan with foil and place your potatoes on top of that. The potatoes will likely bubble over while cooking so it’s good to cook them on a sheet pan. 
  8. Bake in a preheated oven at 375 degrees for 40-45 minutes. 
  9. If you are using the optional parsley garnish, you should chop that now. 
  10. Finely chop the garlic. 
  11. Take the whole fresh peppercorns and grind them in a mortar & pestle if you have one. Add the peppercorns to the mortar and put a small piece of plastic wrap over the pepper. This will prevent them from flying out and making a mess as you grind them. We’re looking for coarsely ground pepper here. If you don’t have a mortar/pestle, see note #2 below for alternative method. 
  12. Place your steaks on a plate or small sheet pan to season. You’ll need a light sprinkling of salt on the top and bottom of the steak. 
  13. Next, add some of the coarse pepper to the top of the steak. You should create a thin layer of pepper here and press down gently as you add it to the top. This is “pepper steak” and when you cook the steak the pepper will become a crisp coating on the top. You won’t use all the pepper here, just enough to coat the top. 
  14. Plan your time with when you start cooking the steaks. It’s good to let the steaks sit on the counter after they’ve been seasoned for about 15 minutes or so. The potatoes take 40-45 minutes. Consider starting to cook the steaks after the potatoes have been cooking for about 30-35 minutes. 
  15. Heat canola oil in a pan on medium-high heat until it’s hot. Add the steaks to the pan pepper side down. Let them cook for 5 minutes – don’t touch. Turn the steaks and cook another 4-5 minutes for medium rare. Additionally, you can turn the steaks on their sides and hold them upright for a few seconds to sear the sides as well. (see video) Cook a few additional minutes for less pink.
  16.  The potatoes will be ready while you’re cooking the steaks. Let them cool down while you finish the steaks and make the sauce. 
  17. After the steaks are done, transfer to a plate and turn heat down a little. Do not clean the pan – there should be some steak drippings there. Add 2 tablespoons of butter to the pan plus the onions, garlic and a pinch of pepper if you like. Cook and stir a couple of minutes or less. Careful not to burn the garlic. The onions are finely diced and won’t take but a minute or two to be translucent. 
  18. Carefully add the cognac to the pan. Be careful it can catch on fire. Either turn down the heat to add or remove pan from the burner to add. 
  19. Turn the heat back to medium and stir the cognac with the onions, garlic and butter. It will take a few minutes at a simmery, light boil for the cognac to reduce by about ¾. My video shows the whole process very well. 
  20. Once the cognac is reduced, add the beef broth and whisk the mixture. The beef broth needs to be reduced by half which will take 2-3 minutes. 
  21. Once the beef broth has reduced the sauce should have a dark color. Time to add the heavy cream a little at a time. You might not need all the cream. I prefer a darker sauce so I didn’t use all of it. Whisk the cream into the sauce, then add 1 tablespoon of butter to help thicken. 
  22. There will be steak juice on the plate where you were resting the steaks. Add that juice to the sauce. Another pinch of pepper if you like. Taste it here. I didn’t think it needed any salt because of the salt from the steaks. If you think it needs a pinch you can add that. Give it one final stir and turn the heat off to let it thicken a bit more. 
  23. Time to plate the food and eat the bite. Place one steak on each plate along with a couple of scoops of the potatoes au gratin. Spoon the sauce over the steaks. Garnish with optional chopped parsley if you want. Enjoy!

Notes

  1. I know sometimes people don’t like to see salt “to taste” on a recipe. But when it comes to salting certain things, you just have to eyeball it. I suggest a light sprinkling of salt on the top and bottom of your steak. My video shows this well. I don’t know the size of the steaks you bought or the thickness. A light sprinkling on the top and bottom is the best I can advice you. 
  2. Alternative for crushing the peppercorns if you don't have a mortar & pestle. Double bag two slider bags and add peppercorns to the bag. Crush the peppercorns with a kitchen mallet or a pan. We’re looking for a coarsely ground pepper here.

Did you make this recipe?

Share a photo and tag us — we can't wait to see what you've made!

« Super Bowl Meatloaf Bites w/Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
Strawberry Love Pie with Sweet Whipped Ricotta »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆

Primary Sidebar

Want to hear about more deliciousness from Eat the Bite?

Sign up for my newsletter and never miss a recipe!

I'll send the latest and greatest right to your inbox!

Social Media Stuff

  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Do You Love Chicken? Here's a Few Recipes to Keep You Busy:

overhead view of balsamic cholula chicken right out of the oven with balsamic vinegar, cholula hot sauce, onions, tomatoes and rosemary

Balsamic Cholula Chicken

small platter of grilled lemon oregano chicken with charred lemons and clark farm peppers

Grilled Lemon Oregano Chicken with Charred Clark Farm Peppers

Dijon Chicken with Apples, Leeks and Fennel: overhead view of platter of chicken on the table with one portion on a plate to the side, bowl of basmati rice, apples, rosemary, fennel on the table

Dijon Chicken with Apples, Leeks and Fennel

Collage of Feeding a crowd for the holidays - 10 best recipes to serve the masses. starting at top left and going clockwise: spaghetti lasagna, jalapeno popper chicken wrapped in bacon, phyllo meat pie, croque monsieur sandwich, creamy chicken bacon pasta, chicken marbella, pork chops with stove top stuffing, steak and sausage pie, stuffed chicken pepperoni pizza bake.

Feeding a Crowd for the Holidays: 10 Best Recipes to Serve the Masses

overhead view of serving platter of creamy chicken bacon pasta garnished with parsley and fresh parmesan with microplane and cheese in the top left corner and a single portion in the top right corner

Creamy Chicken Bacon Pasta (No Butter, No Cream)

very close look a one rosemary balsamic grilled chicken thigh with asparagus in the background

Rosemary Balsamic Grilled Chicken Thighs

side view of a platter of grilled chimichurri chicken thighs with extra sauce and cherry tomatoes

Grilled Chimichurri Chicken Thighs

overview of one portion of cranberry brie stuffed chicken with broccoli and carrots and garnished with parsley

Cranberry Brie Stuffed Chicken

overhead view of the best grilled chicken with marinated tomatoes with one portion plates and a serving bowl of tomatoes, platter of chicken and arugula salad with goat cheese and radish

The Best Grilled Chicken with Marinated Tomatoes

overhead table view of crispy brick chicken with pan sauce, roasted calabaza squash and sauteed zucchini

Crispy Brick Chicken with Pan Sauce and Veggies

back yard bbq front view of platter filled with bacon stuffed cheeseburgers

Backyard BBQ: Sriracha-Lime Chicken, Bacon-Stuffed Cheeseburgers & Twisty Potatoes

overhead view of one portion of cashew chicken stir fry with a serving plate and basmati rice in the background

Cashew Chicken Stir Fry

platter with bone-in stuffed chicken breast with spinach and gouda, rosemary potatoes and salad in background

Bone-in Stuffed Chicken Breast with Spinach and Gouda

front view of sheet pan drumsticks on a platter topped with cilantro and mint

Sheet Pan Drumsticks with Roasted Carrots and Cumin Potatoes

overhead view of both sheet pans with crunchy coconut chicken fingers

Crunchy Coconut Chicken Fingers

Recent Comments

  • Stacey on How to Trim the Fat From Chicken Thighs
  • TheHappyWhisk (Ivy) on How to Trim the Fat From Chicken Thighs
  • Stacey on Ina Garten's Chicken Marbella

Footer

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Copyright © 2023 Eat the Bite on the Foodie Pro Theme