
Sorry turkey, but do we always have to focus on you on Thanksgiving Day? I mean, enough is enough. So turkey, though we've loved you for years (well, actually some of us really don't care for you at all), we've decided to go in another direction this year. And with a warm welcome, let's give a big hug to alternative Thanksgiving with whole roasted chicken with homemade gravy.
The Turkey Dilemma: A Short Story
Tradition is so big around the holidays, right? Like, maybe a little too big. Your grandparents and parents want to eat the same glorious meal every year, with little variation. And I get that. I'm not an un-sentimental person, I have my rituals and traditions too. But this turkey-at-thanksgiving tradition is getting a little old for me. I don't love turkey. I mean, turkey is okay. But I don't love it. My favorite part of Thanksgiving is the next day when I can make a giant turkey gobbler sandwich on really good bread with cranberry sauce, thin sliced onion and sprouts. Other than that, I really just.don't.care.about.turkey.
Whole Roasted Chicken: A Slightly Longer Story
I know there are more of you out there. The people who think turkey is kind of... meh. So make this the year you drop the turkey and embrace whole roasted chicken on the big day. But if your radical idea of no turkey on Thanksgiving doesn't take off, it's okay. You can save this whole roasted chicken for your Christmas dinner. This really is a dinner that can be made for any special occasion.

My absolute favorite protein is chicken. Anyone else? To me, this is the most versatile protein out there and it feels like there are a millions ways to prepare it. With turkey, I mean, what does turkey even have... tetrazzini?!?! I know I've heard that name, but I have no idea what's in it.
Chicken is everywhere and and recipes for chicken are everywhere. But there is something wholeheartedly delightful about roasting a whole chicken. I don't do it enough, but when I do, I vow this is the year I will do it more! And this is the year it will REPLACE turkey on Thanksgiving.
Kosher Salt & ButtermilK-Brined Whole Chicken
My first introduction to preparing a whole chicken this way was in an amazing cookbook called Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat by Samin Nosrat. I made it years ago and was blown away by the flavor and tenderness of it. At the heart of this recipe is the simplicity of buttermilk and kosher salt. This method of brine is whole roasted chicken gold.
The buttermilk is going to break the chicken down so we get a nice, tender end result. And that salt will permeate through the chicken to give us a perfectly seasoned bird.
Things You'll Need to Brine a 7 ½ Pound Whole Chicken:
- A giant zip lock bag (the 2.5 gallon bags. The 1 gallon bags WILL NOT WORK). And this must be a zip lock or slider bag, where it is guaranteed to be 100% sealed when you close the bag.
- Kosher salt
- Buttermilk
- One whole chicken (7.5 pounds)
Would you like to save this?
You'll also be the first to hear about new recipes in my weekly-ish newsletter! 🙂

TWO STEPS To Prep Your Chicken: Get Your chicken salted, Get your Brine Made
1. Generously salt all sides of the chicken with kosher salt. I put some in a ramekin so I could sprinkle it all over the chicken. Let it sit in the salt for 30 minutes.
2. Next, pour all the buttermilk into your 2.5 gallon slider bag and add the kosher salt. Swish it around a little and let it sit for 30 minutes as well. The salt needs to dissolve. Then add the whole chicken into the bag, zip it closed and refrigerate overnight.
How Do Your Know When The Chicken is Done?
I won't mince words here. The most effective way is when the internal temperature of the chicken is 165 degrees. Forget about, "it will be done in exactly two hours!" The best way to know your whole roasted chicken is done, is to check that internal temperature with a thermometer. That being said, for a 7.5 pound chicken you are looking at around 2-2 ¼ hours of cook time.
Chef's Tip for Roasting the Chicken
Everyone's oven is different. My runs hot. When I roast a whole chicken, I definitely have to rotate the pan around the oven a few times while it's cooking. Best thing to keep in mind: Keep your eye on your chicken. When you can see the back of the chicken is nicely browned but the side is not, it's time to rotate your pan.
It's really that simple: watch the chicken, when one part of it is golden brown and another is not: it's time to move it. 🙂 Repeat until you have a nice all-around golden brown.
Alternative Side Dishes for Your No-Turkey Thanksgiving
Okay, if forgoing turkey was a big step, your friends and family may still want traditional sides for the big day.
- If you want to go all the way with alternative Thanksgiving, you can try my cornbread stuffing with sausage (this one is a DOUBLE recipe, so cut it in half for just one 9x13 baking dish of stuffing instead of two.
- You may be disowned if you don't provide mashed potatoes for Thanksgiving dinner, I get that.... but if you're feeling daring I have this delicious potato leek casserole that is to.die.for.
- And if you're tired of a brown-sugar-mapley butternut squash and you're ready to take a walk on the savory side, you should definitely try my savory butternut squash with leeks & thyme.



Thanksgiving: The Whole Shebang if Tradition Reigns Supreme
My first year as a food blogger (about 6 years ago), I made a whole beginner-friendly and budget-friendly Thanksgiving dinner. Though the budget part may be out the window with grocery prices going up so much, this is still a great introduction to making Thanksgiving dinner. Don't put too much pressure on yourself. Most sides you can make ahead of time!
- Thanksgiving Turkey & Gravy
- Fantastic No-Frills Mashed Potatoes
- Easy Pepperidge Farm Stuffing with Apples & Celery
- Steamed Brussel Sprouts w/Toasted Pine Nuts & Bacon Bits
- Sautéed Butternut Squash with Caramelized Leeks & Thyme
- Killer Apple Pie with Butter Crust
Alternative Thanksgiving with Whole Roasted Chicken
- Prep Time: 30 minutes
- Cook Time: 2 hours 30 minutes
- Total Time: 3 hours
- Yield: 4-6 servings 1x
Description
Tired of turkey on Thanksgiving? You might want to try alternative Thanksgiving with whole roasted chicken; brined in buttermilk and salt.
Ingredients
- 1 whole chicken (7 ½ pounds), giblets removed
- 1 medium onion, cut in chunks
- 1 small bunch fresh herbs (rosemary, sage, thyme) – see note 1
- 1 lemon, cut in wedges
- ½ stick of softened salted butter (that’s 4 tablespoons)
- ¾ cup of water for bottom of baking dish
- Olive oil
NOTE: You will need string (kitchen twine – they sell it at the grocery store) to tie the chicken legs together before cooking.
NOTE: You should have a meat thermometer on hand to check internal temperature of the chicken. This is the best way to tell your chicken is done.
For the brine:
- 4 cups of buttermilk
- 2 tablespoons kosher salt
NOTE: You will need a 2 ½ gallon zip lock bag to brine the chicken overnight. A one-gallon bag won’t work on a 7 ½ pound chicken.
For the gravy:
- 3 tablespoons of butter
- 3 tablespoons of all-purpose flour
- 4-5 sage leaves
- 2 cups of chicken broth (I used 2 chicken bouillon cubes in water)
- ½ cup of juices and fat from the pan you cooked the chicken in
- 1 teaspoon veggie or chicken “Better Than Bouillon” – I used veggie, better flavor
- Slurry for thickener (2 tablespoon AP flour, 2 tablespoons water; whisk to make a paste)
- Salt and pepper to taste (I didn’t think it need any)
PREP TIME doesn't include the 12-24 hours for brining the chicken.
Would you like to save this?
You'll also be the first to hear about new recipes in my weekly-ish newsletter! 🙂
Instructions
- My video in the recipe card shows this process well.
- The chicken needs 12-24 hours to marinate in the buttermilk brine so plan to do this the day before your big holiday meal.
- Place your chicken on a large sheet pan and generously salt all sides with some kosher salt. Let it sit for 30 minutes after you’ve salted it.
- Add all the buttermilk to a large 2 ½ gallon slider (ziplock) bag along with the kosher salt. Shake the bag around a little and let it sit on the counter to dissolve the salt in the buttermilk.
- After 30 minutes, swish the buttermilk around in the bag, then place the whole chicken in the bag with the buttermilk and salt. Seal it and squeeze any air out of the bag. I kept it on the sheet pan in my refrigerator. Marinate overnight (12-24 hours). You can turn the bag a few times if you want.
- The next day, take the chicken bag out of the refrigerator and let it sit on the counter an hour to get it closer to room temperature before cooking.
- Take your butter out to soften. It needs to be completely softened by the time we smear it all over the chicken. Preheat your oven to 425 degrees.
- Cut one lemon into lemon wedges. Wash whatever fresh herbs you’re using. If you’re using the “poultry pack” with rosemary, sage, & thyme, pull off 4-5 fresh sage leaves and set aside for the gravy.
- Remove the chicken from the bag and place it on a paper-towel lined sheet pan. Blot the liquid off the chicken until the whole chicken is dry.
- Peel a medium onion and cut into chunks. Scatter the onion on the bottom of a 9x13 baking dish with a small drizzle of olive oil.
- Place the whole chicken on top of the onions, then stuff the herbs and lemon wedges in the chicken cavity.
- Take your softened butter and slather it evenly all over the chicken.
- Cut a long piece of string, place it under the legs of the chicken, then tighten the string to tie the legs together. Tie it in a knot and cut the excess string. You can tuck the wings under if you want or cut them off entirely. I kept them on, but tucked them under a little.
- Add ¾ cup of water to the baking dish before place in the oven.
- Put your chicken in your preheated oven and cook for 20 minutes, then reduce the temperature to 375 degrees.
- Depending on the size of you chicken, it should take about 1 ½ to 1 ¾ hours to cook. You’ll want the internal temperature to be 165 degrees. This is the best way to tell it’s done so you don’t overcook it.
- As the chicken browns in the oven, you should rotate the pan accordingly to make sure the chicken browns evenly. I rotated my pan 2-3 times.
- If you have a baster, you can also baste the chicken in the fat and juices while it’s cooking if you want. I usually do this. While the chicken is out of the oven briefly for basting, you can wrap the wing and leg tips with a little foil if you notice they’re getting burnt.
- Once the chicken is cooked through and has reached an internal temperature of 165 degrees, remove it from the oven and let it cool 15-20 minutes before cutting it. While it’s cooling you can make the homemade gravy.
For the gravy:
- Carefully remove ½ cup of the fat and juices from the baking dish.
- Put your Better Than Bouillon into a small ramekin with a tiny splash of water. Whisk it to become a liquid. It will make it easier to whisk into the gravy.
- Microwave 2 cups of water with 2 chicken bouillon cubes for about 2 minutes. You’ll want the water hot enough that the bouillon cubes dissolve in the water. Press with a fork to break apart the cubes.
- Make the slurry (mix of flour and water).
- Melt the butter in a pot with 4-5 fresh sage leave on low-to-medium heat. Don’t put the heat too high, we don’t want to burn the butter. Just get it sizzling a little so we can pull out some of that nice sage flavor. This should be only a couple of minutes total, then remove the sage leaves.
- Add the flour to the butter and whisk together. Let this cook a few minutes while whisking so we can cook the raw flour flavor out.
- Once the color of the flour and butter has darkened slightly, add the chicken broth, the juices and fat from cooking the chicken, and the Better Than Bouillon. Heat on medium and whisk together. Get it hot enough that it almost comes to a boil. Taste it. Add salt and pepper if you think it needs it. I didn’t add any.
- At this point, you will likely need to thicken it a bit more. Add the slurry and whisk again until it’s well combined. It should be thick enough. Give one final taste. If you think it needs salt and pepper you can add. I didn’t think it needed any additional seasoning.
- Serve your chicken whole and cut it at the table, or slice it ahead of time. Transfer the onions from the baking dish to a serving plate and place the chicken on top of the onions. The onions have a lot of flavor. Serve the gravy on the side.
- You can use your regular traditional sides to serve with this or check mine out from a my previous Thanksgiving Dinner: The Whole Shebang. All the sides I made to photograph with this chicken, are on my website as well. Just remember if you make the cornbread stuffing, the recipe on my site is a DOUBLE recipe which means it makes TWO 9x13 baking dishes of cornbread stuffing so you’ll need to cut the recipe in HALF.
Notes
- Fresh herbs work best for this recipe. You don’t have to buy all three herbs separately. There is one fresh herb pack in the produce section called a “Poultry Pack” that contains all three herbs (rosemary, sage & thyme). You can use the whole pack for the chicken (just set aside 4-5 sage leaves for the gravy).





Leave a Comment